How can an evolutionist such as Jerry Coyne condemn even something as manifestly heinous as the Nazi Holocaust?
The problem of theodicy is real, of course. We don’t always know or understand God’s ways.
Without free will, there is no guilt and there is no innocence. There are merely animals to be managed.
It is flat-out unreasoning — and in my view, anti-human.
No doubt evolutionary psychologists could a tell a story to explain this. They always can. Something about tribes of hunter-gatherers.