I found their review utterly convincing — although probably not in the way the authors might hope.
The signers of the Dissent list have all risked their careers or reputations in signing. Such is the power of groupthink.
Thoughtful reader Steve asks, “Do ID conferences ever have to post something like this?”
Regardless of what you think of her work, I respect the fact that she has generally striven to maintain civility in the Darwin debate.
In Seattle, instead of children, people have dogs.