“Any paper that discusses or describes singularities in the field equations of general relativity is discussing extra-natural objects.”
Harari’s conjecture — “There are no gods” — forms the very basis for everything he says in the rest of the book.
The taproot in question is Darwinism, which “addles the mind” of the Woke elite, the “Ivy-schooled primitives,” whom Zmirak compares with cargo cults.
The practice has a sordid history. There’s always a rationale — for example, in labeling Israeli businesses, or those doing business with Israel, to be avoided.
Quite honestly, I think we should be grateful to people like Coyne and Hawking, who carry materialism to its logical conclusions.