Yes, Nathan Lents, finally we agree: it is “A good day for thoughtful discussion of evolution.”
The conversation is already well underway, with much more stimulation to come.
In one paragraph Lents et al. twice cited sources they thought contradicted Behe, and twice suggested he ignored or dismissed contrary evidence.
Shapiro accepts the idea of evolution, but he also appreciates that intelligent design is ultimately a way of understanding evolution, the mechanism that drives it.
Pointing out the review’s many failings will be the work of multiple articles. Let’s start by zeroing in on just one segment.